458 Island Circle, Sarasota, FL 34242
Single family property built in 2005 with 3,040 sq ft of living area on a 0.16-acre lot in Sarasota, Sarasota County. Facts below come from the county property appraiser's public record.
County just value (tax roll) — not a market value
$1,689,100
County assessed value (tax roll)
$1,596,868
Living area
3,040 sq ft
Lot size
0.16 acres (7,055 sq ft)
Year built
2005
Land use
Single family
FEMA flood zone
Not on file yet
County
Sarasota County, FL
Parcel ID
fl-68-0082110034
At a glance
- Who owns 458 Island Cir?
- Sarasota County property records list TOOLE DAVID STUART as the owner of record.
- What is the county just value of 458 Island Cir?
- $1,689,100 on the Sarasota County tax roll (as of January 1). Just value is the property appraiser's figure for property taxes — not a market value.
- What is the parcel ID?
- fl-68-0082110034 (Sarasota County).
Current owner
- TOOLE DAVID STUART
Owner contact info
Phones, emails and mailing addresses from public Florida records are available to members.
See plansMore on Island Cir
- 421 Island Cir $874K · built 1999
- 430 Island Cir $1.7M · built 1962
- 431 Island Cir $832K · built 1962
- 437 Island Cir $686K · built 1970
- 440 Island Cir $1.5M · built 1994
- 441 Island Cir $835K · built 1959
- 446 Island Cir $1.3M · built 1957
- 451 Island Cir $773K · built 1963
- 454 Island Cir $1.6M · built 2005
- 455 Island Cir $658K · built 1962
- 462 Island Cir $1.1M · built 1988
- 463 Island Cir $837K · built 1971
- 464 Island Cir $852K · built 1952
- 471 Island Cir $1.7M · built 2014
- 472 Island Cir $1.8M · built 2007
- 476 Island Cir $1.5M · built 2005
- 480 Island Cir $1.1M
- 490 Island Cir $3.6M · built 2014
- 497 Island Cir $1.6M · built 2007
- Island Cir $783K
All 121 properties on Island Cir · ZIP 34242 (Sarasota). Values are county just values (tax roll), not market values.
Nearby properties
- 454 Island Cir, Sarasota $1.6M · built 2005
- 462 Island Cir, Sarasota $1.1M · built 1988
- 464 Island Cir, Sarasota $852K · built 1952
- 446 Island Cir, Sarasota $1.3M · built 1957
- 472 Island Cir, Sarasota $1.8M · built 2007
- 463 Island Cir, Sarasota $837K · built 1971
- 476 Island Cir, Sarasota $1.5M · built 2005
- 471 Island Cir, Sarasota $1.7M · built 2014
Explore the area
Search this address on listing sites
These links open the listing site directly; we don't copy their data.
Source: Florida Department of Revenue parcel roll; data refreshed Jun 30, 2026. Values are county tax-roll figures, not appraisals. How to read these values · Data sources