4509 S Pennycress Place, Saint Johns, FL 32259

Single family property built in 2002 with 2,062 sq ft of living area on a 0.17-acre lot in Saint Johns, St. Johns County. Facts below come from the county property appraiser's public record.

Open in interactive map List this home free on dwello Own this home? Claim it

County just value (tax roll) — not a market value

$380,895

County assessed value (tax roll)

$264,127

Living area

2,062 sq ft

Lot size

0.17 acres (7,405 sq ft)

Year built

2002

Land use

Single family

FEMA flood zone

Not on file yet

County

St. Johns County, FL

Parcel ID

fl-65-2495406910

At a glance

Who owns 4509 S Pennycress Pl?: St. Johns County property records list SHUMP TIMOTHY J,MARTHA as the owner of record.
What is the county just value of 4509 S Pennycress Pl?: $380,895 on the St. Johns County tax roll (as of January 1). Just value is the property appraiser's figure for property taxes — not a market value.
What is the parcel ID?: fl-65-2495406910 (St. Johns County).

Current owner

SHUMP TIMOTHY J,MARTHA

Owner contact info

Phones, emails and mailing addresses from public Florida records are available to members.

See plans

Nearby properties

4505 S Pennycress Pl, Saint Johns $307K · built 2003
4513 S Pennycress Pl, Saint Johns $348K · built 2002
828 E Doty Branch Ln, Saint Johns $408K · built 2001
824 E Doty Branch Ln, Saint Johns $369K · built 2002
616 Sparrow Branch Cir, Saint Johns $370K · built 2003
620 Sparrow Branch Cir, Saint Johns $339K · built 2002
829 E Doty Branch Ln, Saint Johns $362K · built 2002
4508 S Pennycress Pl, Saint Johns $364K · built 2002

Explore the area

Search this address on listing sites

These links open the listing site directly; we don't copy their data.

Source: Florida Department of Revenue parcel roll; data refreshed Jun 30, 2026. Values are county tax-roll figures, not appraisals. How to read these values · Data sources