Windley Key, FL property records
Parcel lookup for Windley Key, Florida (Monroe County). Open any parcel for its just value, lot size, year built, land use and FEMA flood zone.
Parcels on file
231
Median just value
$382K
County
Monroe
ZIP codes
33036
Highest-value properties in Windley Key
- 84001 OVERSEAS Hwy, Windley Key $71.4M · built 1973
- 84457 OLD Hwy, Windley Key $19.9M · built 1988
- 84721 OVERSEAS Hwy, Windley Key $11.7M · built 1953
- 84951 OVERSEAS Hwy, Windley Key $11.2M · built 1953
- 85401 OLD Hwy, Windley Key $6.8M · built 2010
- 84801 OVERSEAS Hwy, Windley Key $6.3M · built 2003
- 84959 OVERSEAS Hwy, Windley Key $6.3M · built 1948
- 87431 OLD Hwy, Windley Key $6M · built 1972
- 85289 OLD Hwy, Windley Key $5.8M · built 1983
- 85261 OLD Hwy, Windley Key $5.1M
- 84755 OLD Hwy, Windley Key $4.3M · built 1999
- 84725 OLD Hwy, Windley Key $3.7M
- 84801 OVERSEAS Hwy 10, Windley Key $3.6M · built 1958
- 85361 OVERSEAS Hwy, Windley Key $3.4M · built 1969
- 84775 OLD Hwy, Windley Key $3.1M · built 2000
- 84773 OLD Hwy, Windley Key $3M · built 2000
- 85317 OLD Hwy, Windley Key $3M · built 1963
- 85501 OVERSEAS Hwy, Windley Key $2.8M · built 2020
- 85500 OVERSEAS Hwy, Windley Key $2.5M
- 85327 OVERSEAS Hwy, Windley Key $2.4M · built 2024
- 85331 OVERSEAS Hwy, Windley Key $2.3M · built 2024
- 84341 OVERSEAS Hwy, Windley Key $2.2M · built 1968
- 84371 OVERSEAS Hwy, Windley Key $1.9M · built 1963
- VACANT OLD Hwy, Windley Key $1.9M
- 122 ANGLERS Way, Windley Key $1.9M · built 2007
- 152 ANGLERS Way, Windley Key $1.9M · built 2007
- 84500 OVERSEAS Hwy, Windley Key $1.8M · built 1963
- 84745 OLD Hwy E3, Windley Key $1.8M · built 2023
- 123 ANGLERS Way, Windley Key $1.8M · built 2007
- 147 ANGLERS Way, Windley Key $1.7M · built 2009
Nearby cities in Monroe County
- Key Largo 14,473 parcels
- Mainland 13,914 parcels
- Key West 11,251 parcels
- Big Pine Key 8,616 parcels
- Marathon 6,645 parcels
- Plantation Key 4,042 parcels
- Cudjoe Key 2,882 parcels
- Tavernier 2,339 parcels
- Ocean Reef 2,258 parcels
- Sugarloaf Key 1,772 parcels
- Key Colony Beach 1,533 parcels
- Little Torch Key 1,376 parcels
- Lower Matecumbe Key 1,339 parcels
- Summerland Key 1,328 parcels
- Stock Island 1,316 parcels
- Key Haven 1,313 parcels
- Big Coppitt Key 1,292 parcels
- Upper Matecumbe Key 1,212 parcels
- Ramrod Key 1,199 parcels
- Grassy Key 1,146 parcels
- Middle Torch Key 1,119 parcels
- Big Torch Key 1,070 parcels
- Duck Key 1,029 parcels
- Geiger Key 674 parcels
Counts refreshed 2026-10-12 from county and Florida DOR public records.