Sugarloaf Key, FL property records

Parcel lookup for Sugarloaf Key, Florida (Monroe County). Open any parcel for its just value, lot size, year built, land use and FEMA flood zone.

Open Sugarloaf Key on the map More in Monroe County

Parcels on file

1,772

Median just value

$452K

County

Monroe

ZIP codes

33042

Highest-value properties in Sugarloaf Key

255 CRANE Blvd, Sugarloaf Key $38.8M · built 1999
251 S.r. 939, Sugarloaf Key $10.8M · built 1970
15250 OLD STATE Rd 4A, Sugarloaf Key $10.1M · built 1971
601 S.r. 939, Sugarloaf Key $7.6M · built 2004
17075 OVERSEAS Hwy, Sugarloaf Key $7.1M · built 1968
17279 OLEANDER Ln, Sugarloaf Key $5.9M · built 1958
16750 OLD STATE Rd 4A, Sugarloaf Key $5.6M · built 1959
17137 DOLPHIN St W, Sugarloaf Key $4.6M · built 2002
16780 OLD STATE Rd 4A, Sugarloaf Key $4.3M · built 1958
15520 OLD STATE Rd 4A, Sugarloaf Key $4.1M · built 2014
15620 OLD STATE Rd 4A, Sugarloaf Key $3.8M · built 1963
15680 OLD STATE Rd 4A, Sugarloaf Key $3.8M · built 1973
871 CRANE Blvd, Sugarloaf Key $3.8M · built 1992
16820 OLD STATE Rd 4A, Sugarloaf Key $3.8M · built 2024
1180 SUGARLOAF Blvd, Sugarloaf Key $3.7M · built 1971
17129 AMBERJACK Ln, Sugarloaf Key $3.7M · built 2024
17024 GREEN TURTLE Ln W, Sugarloaf Key $3.3M · built 1979
17373 LA BRISA Ln, Sugarloaf Key $3.2M · built 1949
551 W POINT Dr, Sugarloaf Key $3.2M · built 2018
17138 DOLPHIN St W, Sugarloaf Key $3.1M · built 1983
17013 CORAL Way, Sugarloaf Key $3.1M · built 1981
17111 SEAGRAPE Ln, Sugarloaf Key $3M · built 2022
681 SUGARLOAF Blvd, Sugarloaf Key $3M · built 1971
19551 INDIAN MOUND Dr, Sugarloaf Key $3M · built 2010
18870 ROCKY Rd, Sugarloaf Key $3M · built 2002
731 SUGARLOAF Blvd, Sugarloaf Key $3M · built 2002
17139 LA BRISA Ct, Sugarloaf Key $2.9M · built 1988
17116 HIBISCUS Ln W, Sugarloaf Key $2.9M · built 1999
17387 ALLAMANDA Dr E, Sugarloaf Key $2.9M · built 1990
17034 CORAL Dr, Sugarloaf Key $2.8M · built 2019

Nearby cities in Monroe County

Key Largo 14,473 parcels
Mainland 13,914 parcels
Key West 11,251 parcels
Big Pine Key 8,616 parcels
Marathon 6,645 parcels
Plantation Key 4,042 parcels
Cudjoe Key 2,882 parcels
Tavernier 2,339 parcels
Ocean Reef 2,258 parcels
Key Colony Beach 1,533 parcels
Little Torch Key 1,376 parcels
Lower Matecumbe Key 1,339 parcels
Summerland Key 1,328 parcels
Stock Island 1,316 parcels
Key Haven 1,313 parcels
Big Coppitt Key 1,292 parcels
Upper Matecumbe Key 1,212 parcels
Ramrod Key 1,199 parcels
Grassy Key 1,146 parcels
Middle Torch Key 1,119 parcels
Big Torch Key 1,070 parcels
Duck Key 1,029 parcels
Geiger Key 674 parcels
Long Key 566 parcels

Counts refreshed 2026-10-11 from county and Florida DOR public records.